10 Signs You’re a Cozy Mystery Fanatic

So, you think you’re a cozy mystery fan, do you? Maybe you’ve got a stack of Agatha Christie on your bed side table or perhaps you find yourself daydreaming about moving to a cute little town and solving mysteries. But how can you really tell if you’ve crossed the line from casual fan to full-blown cozy mystery fanatic? Well, let’s have a little fun and see how many of these apply to you! Start counting!

1. You Secretly Think You’d Make an Excellent Amateur Sleuth
Let’s be honest—while you may not have formal detective training, you’re pretty sure your observational skills are second to none. You notice details others miss, you’re always spotting inconsistencies in conversations, and you’ve got a hunch for when something’s just not right. Sure, your actual job might be far less adventurous, but in your heart, you’re an ace sleuth, ready to solve any mystery that comes your way.

2. You’ve Considered Moving to a Cute Village with High Murder Rates
You know the places I’m talking about—charming villages with little cottages, a cozy pub, and lovely community events. Also, it’s a place where people seem to be mysteriously dropping like flies! Somehow, though, that doesn’t scare you off. Quite the opposite, actually. There’s just something about those little communities that feels like the perfect setting for a good whodunit.

3. You Have Strong Feelings about Poirot’s Moustache and Miss Marple’s Knitting
Yes, these details are important! You probably have strong opinions on how these classic characters should be portrayed, and you’d absolutely notice if Poirot’s moustache was even slightly off. For you, these little quirks make the characters real, and you wouldn’t change them for anything.

4. Your Ideal Reading Companion? A Cup of Tea (or Coffee) and a Cozy Blanket
If you’re a true cozy mystery fan, you know that reading is a full sensory experience. You’ve got your book in hand, a warm drink by your side, and you’re snuggled up with a cozy blanket (and maybe a cat if you’re really doing it right). Who needs a crime scene when you’ve got the perfect reading scene?

5. You Secretly Judge Detectives Who Don't Pick Up on Obvious Clues
Admit it—you’ve shouted “It’s right there!” at a character who missed an obvious clue. The main character might be clueless for a little too long, and you find yourself mentally solving the mystery before they even get close. But that’s part of the fun, isn’t it?

6. You’re Always on the Hunt for the Next Series Set in a New (and Unique!) Location
Maybe you’ve read your way through the charming villages of England and are now looking for mysteries set in a vineyard, a beach town, or even the Adelaide Hills (just like my series!). The setting is almost as important as the plot, and you’re always on the lookout for a cozy mystery series that can transport you somewhere new.

7. You Know Exactly What Makes a Mystery “Cozy”
Let’s get one thing straight—a cozy mystery isn’t like any other mystery. It’s all about atmosphere, quirky characters, and that perfect mix of suspense and charm. You know a true cozy mystery doesn’t need gore or grit; it’s more about the puzzle, the characters, and maybe a little lighthearted humor along the way.

8. You Have a Special Place in Your Heart for All Things Whimsical and Quirky
Whether it’s an eccentric baker who just happens to find bodies on her daily walk or a retired librarian who moonlights as a sleuth, you love the quirky side of cozy mysteries. And maybe, just maybe, you wish there were a few more eccentric personalities in your own life!

9. You’re Convinced Your Pet Could Be a Great Sidekick
If you’re a cozy mystery fan, chances are you’re imagining your pet as a detective’s sidekick. That purring cat who seems to know more than they let on, or the loyal dog with a knack for sniffing out the truth—your pet is ready for a starring role in your own personal mystery adventure!

10. You’ll Read Any Mystery as Long as It’s “Cozy” Enough
Murder mystery on a cruise ship? Check. Small-town bakery with a sprinkle of suspense? Check. If it’s cozy, you’re there for it! You know that “cozy” doesn’t just refer to the lack of gore; it’s the feeling of being whisked away to a place where the stakes are high but the setting is oh-so-charming.

So, how many of these did you relate to? If you nodded along to most (or all) of these, congratulations—you are officially a cozy mystery fanatic! And let’s be real, it’s a great club to be in. There’s something so satisfying about sinking into a good cozy mystery, where the world is full of intrigue, charm, and just enough suspense to keep you turning the pages.

If you’re in the mood for a new series (and maybe a trip to the Adelaide Hills?), my own cozy mystery books might be just what you’re looking for. After all, every cozy mystery fanatic deserves a good book (or four) to curl up with!